Everything you love about the classic peanut butter cup candy, elevated into a treat exquisite enough to earn the title as a Crumpets Cookie. Imagine an inside out peanut butter cup, with the rich texture of the peanut butter filling on the outside accentuated by fresh roasted peanuts blended perfectly with sweetened morsels of chocolate.
From the first savory bite, you will be taken on a journey like no other. Savor the intense flavor of roasted peanuts mingling with creamy peanut butter in a mixture like no other. Rich semisweet chocolate bits await you with each bite, providing a sweet escape from the ordinary.
We’ve taken everything you love about a peanut butter cup – and given you more of it to create what is sure to be your new favorite cookie.
Each Peanut Butter Cup Cookie measures between 3 1/2 and 4 inches in diameter.
Allergens: Contains peanuts, milk, wheat, soy & eggs
Important: At this time, we are only able to ship to addresses located in New York State. If you would like to get on our waitlist for shipping outside of New York, please click here to join the waitlist.
Maddie –
The peanut butter cup cookie is absolutely delicious. The peanut-buttery aftertaste made it hard not to go back for seconds! As someone who received the cookies as a surprise gift, I can confidently say that it is a thrill finding such a gorgeous package waiting for me in the mail! The cookies shipped within just a couple of days and held up viry nicely against 80 degree weather and straight sunshine for what must have been several hours. The cookie itself had a soft yet slightly crumbly texture that I just love in peanut butter flavored cookies. The real peanut pieces throughout added a very slight crunch, I loved their addition!
I shared this family this time, and they all agreed completely! The only suggestion we came up with this time was about the possibility of adding geniune peanut butter cups like in the name. I know around here, small ma and pa shops sell mini peanut butter cups and we all thought hahaving a few of those, or even crushed regular ones throughout the cookie would just give it that slight extra peanut butter umph! If you choose not to though, it would not discourage me from getting these again — they were just so good!
Thank you again! As always, (these) did not disappoint!
dorlowski (store manager) –
Thank you for your thoughts! I’m going to try and incorporate the peanut butter cups as you suggested and will post an update when it is finished!